论代孕子女监护权的归属以法规出发型诉讼为视角OACHSSCD
The Attribution of Guardianship for Surrogate Children From the Perspective of the“Action from Norm”Litigation
代孕引发的监护权纠纷，揭示了法律的安定性结构和正义之间的冲突，但正义必须以法规作为基础，也应符合法律规范。以诉讼的出发点的不同可将诉讼划分为法规出发型和事实出发型，大陆法系的诉讼属于前者，英美法系的诉讼属于后一类型。我国法律制度无疑为大陆法系的成文法法律制度，因此，诉讼的出发点只能是现行法的有效规范。在解决因代孕引发的监护权纠纷时，不得以道德的、个人或阶层的正义观念替代法律规定，必须依照法律的规定予以裁决。就本文案例而言，依照儿童利益最大化原则的…查看全部>>
Guardianship dispute raised by surrogacy reveals conflict between stability structure of law and justice. But justice must be based on laws and regulations and it should accord with legal norm. According to the different starting point of litigation, there are the law-driven stand and the fact-driven stand. And the litigation of civil law system belongs to the former and the common law system belongs to the latter. There is no doubt that legal system in our …查看全部>>
谢文哲;刘正川
华东政法大学法律学院，上海 200042华东政法大学法律学院，上海 200042
社会科学
代孕监护法规出发型诉讼事实出发型诉讼儿童利益最大化
surrogacyguardianshipthe law-driven standthe fact-driven standmaximizing interests of children
《西南石油大学学报（社会科学版）》 2016 (6)
68-73,6
评论