民事诉讼测谎意见证据地位的实证考察与理论反思——以北大法宝188份民事判决书为分析样本OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCI
An Empirical Investigation and Theoretical Reflection on the Evidence Position of the Polygraph Opinion in Civil Litigation——An analysis of 188 civil judgments on Pkulaw.cn
证据属性理论于司法实践有着重要的指导意义.在我国,证据"三属性"说具有并列性和以客观性为中心的特点,加之缺乏统一严密的证据审查规范,导致在民事诉讼中,法官对测谎意见的证据评价陷入三个"怪圈".对比英美法系国家证据属性理论,其具有层次性和以关联性为中心的特点,辅之严格的证据审查规范,法官对测谎意见的证据评价与适用有着更为清晰的思路.当前,测谎意见在我国民事诉讼中的运用更多地表现为一种盲目和混乱.因此,从根本上重构我国的证据属性理论,通过规则的设计规…查看全部>>
The theory of evidence attributes has important guiding significance for judicial practice.In our country,the "three attributes"of evidence has the features of parallelism and objectivity centered,together with the lack of unified and rigorous evidence review standards,so the judge's evaluation of polygraph opinion falls into three "strange circles".Comparing the countries of the Anglo-American legal system,the theory of evidence attribute has the characteri…查看全部>>
栗明
浙江大学 光华法学院,浙江 杭州 310008
社会科学
测谎意见证据属性理论证据能力证明力证据规则
polygraph opinionthe theory of evidence attributesadmissibility of evidencevalue of evidencerules of evidence
《河北法学》 2018 (5)
52-68,17
国家社科基金一般项目《当事人平等原则与民事证明减轻体系建构研究》(16BFX094)阶段性成果
评论