数字化治疗依从性技术在肺结核患者服药管理中的应用效果评价OACSTPCD
Evaluation of the application effect of digital therapeutics adherence technology in medication management of tuberculosis patients
目的:评价数字化治疗依从性技术(digital treatment adherence technologies,DAT)的实施效果,以进一步提高新疆维吾尔自治区(以下简称"新疆")昌吉州结核病患者治疗及服务管理质量.方法:采取回顾性研究方法,从中国疾病预防控制中心"结核病管理信息系统"和"易督导"网站中导出2021年1月1日至2023年3月31日登记现住址为"新疆维吾尔自治区昌吉州5县2市"且完成治疗疗程的活动性肺结核患者相关临床资料.根据患者管理方式,将2021年1月1日至12月31日登记为肺结核但未使用"易督导"管理系统的403例患者纳入传统方式管理组(传统组),将2022年1月1日至2023年3月31日登记为肺结核且使用"易督导"管理系统的313例患者纳入DAT管理组(DAT组),DAT使用率为89.68%(313/349),再根据使用电子工具的不同将DAT组分为电子药盒管理组[药盒组;81例(25.88%)]和微信公众号管理组[微信组;232例(74.12%)].分析传统组和DAT组患者人口学特征、服药依从性及治疗效果,以及DAT组使用DAT的情况及不同地区的管理情况.结果:微信组在≥60岁年龄组[30.60%(71/232)]和农牧民[40.95%(95/232)]的占比均明显低于药盒组[77.78%(63/81)和76.54%(62/81)],差异均有统计学意义(x2=54.780,P=0.000;x2=32.666,P=0.000).传统组总体服药率[97.78%(99 053/101 299)]和规则服药率[96.03%(387/403)]均优于 DAT 组[分别为 93.23%(62 601/67 146)和85.62%(268/313)],药盒组总体服药率[95.89%(15 808/16 486)]优于微信组[92.37%(46 793/50 660)],差异均有统计学意义(x2=2162.210、24.481、244.306,P值均=0.000),但微信组规则服药率[84.48%(196/232)]与药盒组[88.89%(72/81)]差异无统计学意义(x2=0.947,P=0.331).DAT 组的治疗成功率[95.85%(300/313)]、第2/3个月末查痰率[99.36%(311/313)]和痰菌阴转率[98.76%(159/161)]与传统组[分别为94.29%(380/403)、98.26%(396/403)和 97.83%(271/277)]的差异均无统计学意义(x2=0.891,P=0.345;x2=0.941,P=0.332;x2=0.106,P=0.744),但微信组治疗成功率[98.28%(228/232)]高于药盒组[88.89%(72/81)],差异有统计学意义(x2=11.036,P=0.001).DAT组不同地区规则服药率介于61.22%(30/49)~97.30%(36/37),差异有统计学意义(x2=39.320,P=0.000).结论:新疆昌吉州各县(市)接受使用DAT管理的肺结核患者比例较高,且以接受微信公众号管理为主,可更准确地反映患者服药情况,管理效果也与传统管理方式一致.应针对不同县市、不同管理方式、不同年龄、不同职业人群制定不同的DAT管理措施,以提高规则服药率,并逐步在新疆地区推广应用.
Objective:To evaluate the implementation effect of digital treatment adherence technologies(DAT)and further improve the quality of treatment and service management for active pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Changji Prefecture,Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region(referred to as"Xinjiang").Methods:A retrospective study was conducted.Clinical data of active pulmonary tuberculosis patients registered with current addresses in"Changji Prefecture,Xinjiang(5 counties and 2 cities)"from January 1,2021,to March 31,2023,were exported from the"Tuberculosis Information Management System"and the"Easy Supervision"website of the Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention.Based on the patient management method,403 patients registered as pulmonary tuberculosis from January 1 to December 31,2021,but not using the"Easy Supervision"system were included in the traditional management group(traditional group).Additionally,313 patients registered as pulmonary tuberculosis from January 1,2022,to March 31,2023,and using the"Easy Supervision"system were included in the DAT management group(DAT group).The DAT utilization rate was 89.68%(313/349).Further categorization of the DAT group based on the use of electronic tools resulted in the Electronic Medication Box management group(Medication Box group;81 cases(25.88%))and the WeChat official account management group(WeChat group;232 cases(74.12%)).The population demographics,medication adherence,treatment outcomes,DAT usage in the DAT group,and management conditions in different regions were analyzed.Results:The WeChat group had significantly lower proportions in the age group ≥60 years(30.60%(71/232))and among farmers and herdsmen(40.95%(95/232))compared to the Medication Box group(77.78%(63/81)and 76.54%(62/81)),and the differences were statistically significant(x2=54.780,P=0.000;x2=32.666,P=0.000).The Traditional Group had higher overall medication adherence rates(97.78%(99 053/101 299))and regular medication adherence rates(96.03%(387/403))than the DAT management group(93.23%(62 601/67 146)and 85.62%(268/313)),the Medication Box group's overall medication adherence rate(95.89%(15 808/16 486))was higher than the WeChat group(92.37%(46 793/50 660)),and the differences were statistically significant(x2=2162.210,24.481,244.306,all P values=0.000).However,there was no statistically significant difference in regular medication adherence rates between the WeChat group(84.48%(196/232))and the Medication Box group(88.89%(72/81))(x2=0.947,P=0.331).The treatment success rate(95.85%(300/313)),sputum examination rate at the end of the 2nd/3rd month(99.36%(311/313)),and sputum smear conversion rate(98.76%(159/161))in the DAT group were not statistically different from those in the traditional group(94.29%(380/403),98.26%(396/403),and 97.83%(271/277)),respectively(x2=0.891,P=0.345;x2=0.941,P=0.332;x2 0.106.P=0.744).However,the WeChat group's treatment success rate(98.28%(228/232))was higher than that of the Medication Box group(88.89%(72/81)),and the difference was statistically significant(x2=11.036,P=0.001).The regular medication adherence rates in different regions of the DAT management group ranged from 61.22%(30/49)to 97.30%(36/37),and the difference was statistically significant(x2=39.320,P=0.000).Conclusion:The proportion of pulmonary tuberculosis patients in Changji Prefecture,Xinjiang,accepting DAT management is relatively high,with WeChat official account management being the primary method.This method can more accurately reflect patient medication conditions,and the management effect is consistent with traditional management methods.Different DAT management measures should be developed for different counties,cities,management methods,ages,and occupational groups in order to improve regular medication adherence rates.The application of DAT should be gradually promoted in Xinjiang.
张晗;王丽霞;魏玉石;赵瑞;王新旗;刘年强;王森路
新疆维吾尔自治区疾病预防控制中心现场流行病学培训项目,乌鲁木齐 830002||新疆维吾尔自治区昌吉州疾病预防控制中心结核病防治科,昌吉 831100新疆维吾尔自治区昌吉州疾病预防控制中心结核病防治科,昌吉 831100新疆维吾尔自治区疾病预防控制中心现场流行病学培训项目,乌鲁木齐 830002
临床医学
结核,肺病例管理结果与过程评价(卫生保健)手机微信APP电子药盒
Tuberculosis,pulmonaryCase managementOutcome and process assessment(health care)Mobile phone WeChatMedicine monitor
《中国防痨杂志》 2024 (002)
158-164 / 7
新疆维吾尔自治区卫生健康青年医学科技人才专项科研项目(WJWY-202242);新疆维吾尔自治区科学技术协会青年人才托举工程项目(RCTJ42)Special Scientific Research Project for Healthy Young Medical Science and Technology Talents of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region(WJWY-202242);Science and Technology Association Youth Talent Promotion Project of Xinjiang Uygur Autonomous Region(RCTJ42)
评论