骨化核对发育性髋关节脱位术后股骨头缺血性坏死的影响研究OA北大核心CSTPCD
Effect of ossification on avascular necrosis of femoral head after operation for developmental dysplasia of the hip
目的 探讨股骨头骨化核对6~24月龄发育性髋关节脱位(developmental dysplasia of the hip,DDH)患儿治疗后发生股骨头缺血性坏死(avascular necrosis of femoral head,AVN)的影响.方法 回顾性分析2018年1月至2022年1月期间在昆明市儿童医院接受石膏固定术治疗的6~24月龄DDH患儿的髋关节临床资料.依据末次随访时患髋股骨头是否坏死分为:AVN(+)组(Kalamchi-MacEwen分型Ⅰ~Ⅳ型)、AVN(-)组(Kalamchi-MacEwen分型未见坏死);根据股骨头是否出现临床坏死分为临床 AVN(+)组(Kalamchi-MacEwen 分型 Ⅱ~Ⅳ型)、临床 AVN(-)组(Kalamchi-MacEwen 分型 Ⅰ 型或未见坏死);根据手术年龄分为6~12月龄组、12~18月龄组和18~24月龄组.比较AVN(+)组与AVN(-)组患儿性别、患髋骨化核状态、侧别、手术年龄、手术方式、术前国际髋关节发育不良协会(Interna-tional Hip Dysplasia Institute,IHDI)分型、术前髋臼指数(acetabular index,AI)值、外展角度,采用二元Logistic回归分析评估DDH术后发生AVN的独立影响因素,基于独立影响因素绘制受试者操作特征(receiver operating characteristic,ROC)曲线评估其对DDH术后发生AVN的诊断效能.对比临床AVN(+)组与临床AVN(-)组患髋的骨化核状态,分析骨化核状态对临床AVN的影响.对比6~12月龄组、12~18月龄组、18~24月龄组患髋AVN发生率、临床AVN发生率、再脱位发生率、残余髋臼发育不良(residual acetabular dysplasia,RAD)发生率.结果 本研究共纳入 221 髋.AVN(+)组 54 髋,AVN(-)组167髋.患髋中有骨化核者AVN发生率为18.1%(27/149),无骨化核者ANV发生率为37.5%(27/72),有骨化核者AVN发生率显著低于无骨化核者(P=0.002).多因素Logistic回归分析发现,骨化核状态(OR=3.064,95%CI:1.486~6.319)、外展角度(OR=1.184,95%CI:1.110~1.264)、术前 IH-DI 分型(OR=3.821,95%CI:1.465~9.968)是 DDH 术后发生 AVN 的独立影响因素(P<0.05).ROC曲线分析显示外展角度预测DDH术后发生AVN的最佳截断值为63.5°,曲线下面积(area under curve,AUC)为0.752,灵敏度为0.500,特异度为0.934.有骨化核者临床AVN发生率为14.1%,无骨化核者临床ANV发生率为26.4%,有骨化核者临床AVN发生率显著低于无骨化核者(P=0.026).6~12月龄组、12~18月龄组、18~24月龄组AVN发生率分别为20.0%、31.7%、46.1%,临床AVN发生率分别为11.3%、25.0%、26.1%,再脱位发生率分别为1.7%、8.3%、13.0%,RAD发生率分别为27.0%、45.0%、54.3%;3个手术年龄组间比较,AVN发生率差异均无统计学意义(P=0.224),但临床AVN发生率、再脱位发生率和RAD发生率差异均有统计学意义(P<0.05).结论 骨化核状态、外展角度、术前IHDI分型是DDH患髋术后发生AVN的独立影响因素.骨化核出现对股骨头具有保护作用,可显著降低AVN及临床AVN的发生率,但随着年龄增大,临床AVN发生率、再脱位发生率和RAD发生率增高,会导致相对不良的预后,因此建议在有复位指征时尽早进行DDH治疗,无需等待骨化核出现.
Objective To explore the effect of ossified nuclei on avascular necrosis of femoral head(AVN)in children aged 6-24 month with developmental dysplasia of the hip(DDH)and examine whether or not DDH therapy should be deferred until the emergence of ossified nuclei.Methods The clinical data of hip joint in children with DDH aged 6 to 24 months who received plaster fixation in Kunming Children's Hospital from January 2018 to January 2022 were retrospectively analyzed.According to the necrosis of the hip head at the last follow-up,it was divided into:AVN(+)group(Kalamchi-MacEwen type Ⅰ~Ⅳ),AVN(-)group(Kalamchi-MacEwen type no necrosis),The femoral head was divided into clinical AVN(+)group(Kalam-chi-MacEwen type Ⅱ to Ⅳ)and clinical AVN(-)group(Kalamchi-MacEwen type Ⅰ or no necrosis)accord-ing to whether clinical necrosis occurred,and were divided into 6 to 12 months of age group,12 to 18 months of age group and 18 to 24 months of age group according to operative age.The ossified nucleus status,gender,side,age,mode of operation,preoperative IHDI classification,preoperative Al value,and abduction Angle of the affected hip were compared between the AVN(+)group and the AVN(-)group,and the independent influ-encing factors of postoperative AVN were evaluated by multivariate Logistic regression analysis.receiver operat-ing characteristic curve(ROC)was drawn based on independent influencing factors to evaluate its diagnostic efficacy for postoperative AVN after DDH.The status of ossified nucleus of hip in clinical AVN(+)group and clinical AVN(-)group were compared to analyze the influence of ossified nucleus status on clinical AVN.The incidence of AVN,clinical AVN,redislocation and residual acetabular dysplasia(RAD)of the affected hip in the 6-12 months age group,the 12-18 months age group and the 18-24 months age group were analyzed.Results A total of 221 hips were included in the study.The AVN(+)group had 54 hips and the AVN(-)group had 167 hips.In all affected hips,the incidence of AVN with ossified nucleus was 18.1%,and the inci-dence of ANV without ossified nucleus was 37.5%.The incidence of AVN with ossified nucleus was significant-ly lower than that without ossified nucleus(P=0.002).Multivariate Logistic regression analysis showed that the status of ossified nucleus(OR=3.064,95%CI:1.486-6.319),abducting Angle(OR=1.184,95%CI:1.110-1.264),preoperative IHDI classification(OR=3.821,95%CI:1.465~9.968)were independent in-fluencing factors for postoperative AVN after DDH(P<0.05).ROC Curve analysis showed that the best trun-cation value of abduction Angle for predicting AVN after DDH was 63.5°,the Area Under Curve(AUC)was 0.752,the sensitivity was 0.500,and the specificity was 0.934.The incidence of clinical AVN in patients with ossified nucleus was 14.1%,and the incidence of clinical ANV in patients without ossified nucleus was 26.4%.The incidence of clinical AVN in patients with ossified nucleus was significantly lower than that in pa-tients without ossified nucleus(P=0.026).The incidence of AVN in 6-12 months,12-18 months and 18-24 months age groups was 20.0%,31.7%and 46.1%,respectively.The clinical incidence of AVN was 11.3%,25.0%and 26.1%,and the rate of redislocation was 1.7%,8.3%and 13.0%,respectively.The RAD rates were 27.0%,45.0%and 54.3%,respectively.There was no significant difference in the incidence of AVN among the three operative age groups(P=0.224),but the incidence of AVN and redislocation were clinically significant.Conclusions The status of ossified nucleus,abduction Angle and preoperative IHDI type were independent fac-tors for postoperative AVN in DDH affected hips.The appearance of ossified nucleus has a protective effect on the femoral head and can significantly reduce the incidence of AVN and clinical AVN.However,with the increase of age,the incidence of clinical AVN,the rate of re-dislocation and the rate of RAD will increase,which will lead to a worse prognosis.Therefore,it is recommended that DDH treatment should be performed as soon as possible when there are indications of reduction,without waiting for the appearance of ossified nucleus.
鲁婵;唐兹诞;康晓鹏;周游
昆明市儿童医院骨科,昆明 650000
发育性髋关节脱位股骨头缺血性坏死外科手术儿童
Ossified Nucleus of Femoral HeadDevelopmental Dysplasia of The HipSurgical Proce-dures,OperativeChild
《临床小儿外科杂志》 2024 (003)
216-222 / 7
云南省杨军林专家工作站(202205AF150062) Yunnan Provincial Yang Junlin Expert Workstation(202205AF150062)
评论