|国家科技期刊平台

论碳排放权的法律属性OACHSSCDCSSCI

On Legal Attribute of Carbon Emission Rights

中文摘要英文摘要

碳排放权具有保护环境公共利益和控排企业私人财产利益的双重法律意义,因市场机制必须经过政府管控才能发挥减排效用,所以碳排放权受到行政规制具有正当性和必要性.政府没有干预碳排放权中财产利益的目的,碳排放权本身也没有对抗政府规制之意,因此,以权利受到行政规制为由认定碳排放权具有公法属性不符合公权利的定义.初始分配和清缴配额环节的公法属性或源于政府对配额的管理,或源于行政法律义务,但都无关碳排放权的法律属性.除了可交易性特征,碳排放权对控排企业支配配额财产的保护,碳排放权法律关系的自愿性和平等性都表明了碳排放权是私法权利.

Carbon emission rights have a dual nature of protecting the public interest of the environment and controlling the private interest of emission control enterprises in quotas.As market mechanisms must be regulated by the government in order to achieve emission reduction effects,administrative regulation of carbon emission rights is legitimate and necessary.The government has no intention of intervening in the property interests of carbon emission rights,and the rights themselves have no intention of opposing government regulations.Therefore,the recognition of carbon emission rights as having public law attributes under administrative regulation does not conform to the definition of public rights.The public law attributes of the initial allocation and clearance of quotas are either derived from the government's management of quotas or from administrative legal obligations,but they are not related to the legal attributes of carbon emission rights.In addition to its tradability characteristics,carbon emission rights protect the allocation of quota assets by emission control enterprises,and the voluntariness and equality of the legal relationship of carbon emission rights indicate that carbon emission rights are private law rights.

陈敬林

武汉大学 法学院,湖北 武汉 430072

政治法律

碳排放权法律属性碳排放配额碳排放权交易碳排放权管理

《南京工业大学学报(社会科学版)》 2024 (002)

82-92 / 11

国家社会科学基金重点项目"完善正确处理新形势下人民内部矛盾之大调解制度研究"(20AZD083)

评论