|国家科技期刊平台
首页|期刊导航|重庆高教研究|基于评教文本挖掘的高校教学质量评价指标构建与应用

基于评教文本挖掘的高校教学质量评价指标构建与应用OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCI

Construction and Application of University Teaching Quality Evaluation Index Based on Teaching Evaluation Text Mining

中文摘要英文摘要

学生评教既是保障教学质量的重要活动,又是高校进行教学质量评价的主要手段.为提高教学评价效果,为授课教师和教学管理部门提供更有参考性的评教结果,区别于主要基于学生结构化评分数据进行的定量研究和基于非结构化评教文本数据进行的定性研究,基于大数据评教文本挖掘的研究方式被提上研究议程.以学生主观评语和客观评分两方面的评教数据为研究对象,采用层次分析法构建基于评教文本挖掘的高校教学质量评价指标体系,并通过线性回归方法对指标体系的科学性进行实证检验和应用分析.研究发现,海量学生评教数据兼具学术研究价值和实践指导意义.通过对学生评教文本进行挖掘和分析,以有效获取评教数据中的关键信息,如教师的教学态度、教学内容、教学能力、教学方法和教学效果等.基于层次分析法构建的5个维度23个层级的高校教学质量评价指标体系,能够较为全面、准确地利用学生评教数据对本科教学质量进行评价和解释.多元线性回归分析结果显示,该指标体系不仅能够了解学生重点关注的维度、预测学生评价分数并揭示教师教学质量与各个评价维度之间的关系,还可以应用于各类教师的教学质量评价,从而为教师提供精细化的教学诊断,为学校进行科学的教学管理决策提供数据咨询与服务支持.该评价指标体系的实际应用评价结果显示,不同类别课程存在的问题不同.为此,一方面要通过大数据、人工智能等新兴技术手段提高对学生评教数据的利用效率,深度挖掘海量学生评教数据背后的数据价值和学术研究价值,并加强与同行评教、督导评教和AI评教等不同视角评教结果的协同运用,开展基于学生中心和产出导向的教学评价应用;另一方面需要针对不同类别课程和不同年龄段教师的教学薄弱环节进行针对性教学改进,从而更好地服务高校教学质量的持续提升和学生的全面发展.

Student evaluation of teaching is not only an important activity to ensure teaching quality,but also the main means for universities to evaluate teaching quality.In order to improve the effectiveness of teaching evaluation and provide more reference teaching results for instructors and educational administration departments,the research approach based on big data teaching text mining should be put on the research a-genda,which is different from quantitative research mainly based on structured student rating data and quali-tative research based on unstructured teaching text data.Based on the subjective and objective evaluation da-ta of students,the Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP)was used to construct a university teaching quality e-valuation index system based on evaluation text mining.The scientific validity of the index system was em-pirically tested and applied through linear regression analysis.Research has found that a massive amount of student evaluation data has both academic research value and practical guidance significance.By mining and analyzing student evaluation texts,the key information in evaluation data can be effectively obtained,such as the instructors'teaching attitude,content,ability,methods,and effectiveness.A university teaching quality evaluation index system with 5 dimensions and 23 levels constructed based on the AHP can comprehensively and accurately use student evaluation data to evaluate and elaborate the quality of undergraduate teaching.The results of multiple linear regression analysis show that the indicator system can not only understand the dimensions that students focus on,predict student evaluation scores,and reveal the relationship between in-structors teaching quality and various evaluation dimensions,but can also be applied to the evaluation of teaching quality for various types of instructors,providing refined teaching diagnosis for instructors and data consulting and service support for scientific teaching management decisions in schools.The practical applica-tion evaluation results of the evaluation index system show that the problems existing in different categories of courses are significantly different.Therefore,on the one hand,it is necessary to improve the efficiency of utilizing student evaluation data through various emerging technologies such as big data and artificial intelli-gence,deeply explore the data value and academic research value,behind the massive amount of student e-valuation data,and strengthen the collaborative application of evaluation results from different perspectives such as peer evaluation,supervisory evaluation,and AI evaluation,and carry out student-centered and out-put oriented teaching evaluation applications;on the other hand,targeted teaching improvements are needed to address the teaching weaknesses of instructors in different categories of courses and age groups,in order to better serve the continuous improvement of teaching quality in universities and the comprehensive develop-ment of students.

李建龙;李立国

中国人民公安大学 教务处,北京 100038中国人民大学 教育学院,北京 100872

教育学

学生评教文本高校教学质量评价指标体系教学诊断教学改进学生发展

student evaluation textsevaluation index system of teaching quality in colleges and univer-sitiesteaching diagnosisteaching improvementstudent's development

《重庆高教研究》 2024 (003)

11-24 / 14

北京市教育科学"十四五"规划青年专项课题"高等教育数字化转型背景下学生评教文本的实证研究"(CDCA23126)

10.15998/j.cnki.issn1673-8012.2024.03.002

评论