从"拔尖"到"乐群":小 组合作学习与拔尖创新人才培养OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCI
From Top-notch to Spirit of Community:Group Cooperation Learning and Top-notch Talents Cultivation
在拔尖创新人才的培养中,互相启发和学习的群体氛围十分重要.当前对拔尖创新人才的研究主要集中在政策制度等宏观层面,较少关注同伴关系和群体合作等微观层面.作为高校常见的教学形式,小组作业可成为考察同伴关系与群体合作影响拔尖创新人才培养的切入点.选取某一流大学的不同专业学生,通过访谈和观察搜集资料,分析当前小组合作过程中的合作与学习文化,及其对拔尖创新人才培养的影响.研究发现:在组队方式上,小组合作主要为"熟人组队",以此防范合作风险;小组主要以具有核心成员的"星状小组"模式进行分工与合作,这有助于提升小组工作效率,但同时也降低了其他组员的积极性.在评价方式上,组内和组间等多重评价相结合,对同伴关系和合作效果产生了复杂影响;突出教师权威的师生关系影响了小组作业的成果形式或风格,反映了教师占据主导、学生迎合教师的教学权力关系.在文化上,普遍存在"以和为贵"的合作文化,既有助于提高效率,但也会阻碍学术创新.这反映出在优绩主义评价制度下学生学习和合作的异化:基于博弈的人我观使同伴变为竞争对手或被利用的对象;基于功利的学习观易走向迎合考评的"表现性学习",学习的内在价值被削弱.小组作业中的"工具性合作"有助于提升"分工—执行"的效率,但可能陷入创新的"范式陷阱".因此,拔尖创新人才的培养还应加入"乐群"这一群体支持维度,通过涵育学生之间团结协作、友爱互助的精神,对"志趣""拔尖"与"创新"的养成产生促进作用.为促进小组合作和拔尖创新人才培养,应建立共同契约、创设安全氛围、变革评价方式、强调学术精神,以解决市场逻辑和学术逻辑以及不同培养目标之间的冲突.
In the cultivation of top innovative talents,it is very important to form a group atmosphere of mutual inspiration and learning.However,the current research on top innovative talents mainly focuses on the macro level such as policy and system but pays less attention to the micro level such as peer relation-ship.As a common pedagogical practices in universities,groupwork is a key to investigate the influence of peer relationship and group cooperation on the training quality of top innovative talents.The study selected students from different majors in a first-class university,collected materials through interviews and observa-tions,and attempted to analyze the learning and cooperation culture in the current group cooperation process,and its impact on the cultivation of top innovative talents.The study found that:team formation is mainly based on acquaintances,which can better prevent risks;the group structure is mainly star-shaped group with one core member,which promotes the group efficiency but hinders the enthusiasm of other members.In terms of evaluation methods,the combination of intra-group and inter-group evaluation has a complex impact on cooperation effects.The teacher-student relationship dominated by teacher authority al-so has an impact on group cooperation,reflecting the teacher-dominated power.In culture,there is a common cooperative culture of"harmony being the most valuable",which not only promotes cooperation,but also hinders academic innovation,reflecting the alienation of students'learning and cooperation in the meritocracy evaluation system.Driven by the game-based view of interpersonal relationship,peers become competitors or objects to be used.The utilitarian view of learning has brought about"performance learn-ing"catering to evaluation system,which undermines the value of learning.The instrumental collaboration in groupwork ensures high efficiency of accomplishing tasks,but it may fall into the"paradigm trap"which inhibits innovation.Therefore,the"Spirit of Community"(Le Qun),i.e.a group support dimension,should be noted when cultivating top innovative talents.It helps promote the cultivation of"aspiration","top-notch"and"innovation"by cultivating the solidarity,cooperation,friendship,and mutual help a-mong students.To promote group cooperation and the cultivation of top innovative talents,we should es-tablish a common contract,create a safe atmosphere,reform evaluation methods,emphasize academic spirit,so as to solve the conflict between market logic and academic logic,and conflict among different cultivation targets.
张仁杰;寇焜照
北京大学 教育学院,北京 100871北京外国语大学 国际教育学院,北京 100089
教育学
小组合作学习拔尖创新人才同伴关系优绩主义
group cooperation learningtop-notch innovative talentspeer relationshipmeritocracy
《重庆高教研究》 2024 (003)
69-81 / 13
中国博士后科学基金面上资助项目"种族关系与美国大学招生公平性研究"(2023M730315);中国高等教育学会高等教育科学研究规划课题"亚裔与美国大学招生政策变迁研究"(23ZK0408)
评论