出国留学对博士生能力发展的影响OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCI
The Influence of Studying Abroad on the Ability Development of Doctoral Students:An Analysis Based on the Data of Nature Global Survey
在全球化和知识经济时代,高等教育国际化程度不断加剧,博士研究生国际流动规模日益扩大,留学博士生的能力发展情况成为高等教育领域关注的话题.基于2019年Nature全球博士生调查数据,采用普通最小二乘法回归、倾向得分匹配法和分位数回归等方法研究出国留学对博士生能力发展的影响.实证结果发现:出国留学对全球博士生的学术能力发展具有显著的负向影响,该负向影响效应随着博士生能力水平的上升而呈现减弱趋势.相反,出国留学对全球博士生的通用能力发展具有显著的正向影响,该正向影响效应随着博士生能力水平的上升呈现先增强后减弱的趋势.从国别来看,在中国,留学博士生的学术能力发展情况较好,但通用能力发展相对不足.相反,在英国和美国,留学博士生的通用能力发展程度优于学术能力发展.导师指导对博士生学术能力发展具有显著的正向影响,且能够削弱出国留学对博士生学术能力发展的负向影响,但对留学博士生通用能力发展的主效应和调节效应均不显著.基于此,建议我国高校优化博士生培养模式以提升留学博士生的通用能力;博士生导师转变培养理念并制定有针对性的培养计划;留学博士生要明晰自身发展定位并增强跨文化学习适应性.
In the era of globalization and knowledge economy,the internationalization of higher educa-tion is constantly deepening and the scale of international flow of doctoral students is expanding.The ability development of doctoral students studying abroad has become a topic worthy of attention and discussion in the field of higher education.Based on the data of the 2019 Nature Global Doctoral Survey,the methods of ordinary least squares regression,propensity score matching and quantile regression were used to study the influence of studying abroad on the ability development of doctoral students.The empirical results show that studying abroad has a significant negative effect on the academic ability development of overseas doctoral students,and the negative effect shows a weakening trend with the increase of doctoral students'ability level.On the contrary,studying abroad has a significant positive effect on the general ability development of overseas doctoral students,while the positive effect shows a trend of strengthening first and then weakening with the increase of doctoral students'ability level.From the perspective of different countries,in China,the academic ability development of overseas doctoral students is better,but the general ability development is insufficient.On the contrary,in the United Kingdom and the United States,the general ability develop-ment of overseas doctoral students is better,while the academic ability development is lower.In addition,supervisor's guidance plays an important role in the overseas academic training of doctoral students.It is found that supervisor's guidance has a significant positive influence on the development of doctoral students'academic ability,and it can weaken the negative impact of studying abroad on the academic ability development of them.However,the main effect and moderating effect of supervisor's guidance on the general ability development of overseas doctoral students are not significant.It is suggested that university in China should optimize the doctoral cultivation model to improve the general ability of overseas doctoral students;the supervisor should transform their cultivation concept and adopt targeted training arrangements;overseas doctoral students also should clear their own development orientation and enhance the adaptability of cross-cultural learning.
袁玉婷;汪雅霜
南京大学 教育研究院,南京 210023
教育学
出国留学博士研究生能力发展博士生教育高等教育国际化
studying abroaddoctoral studentsability developmentdoctoral educationinternationa-lization of higher education
《重庆高教研究》 2024 (003)
97-110 / 14
江苏省社会科学基金青年项目"江苏'双一流'建设大学科研绩效评价与拨款机制研究"(17JYC002)
评论