基层形式主义困局何以发生与矫治?OA北大核心CHSSCD
How Does the Grass-Roots Formalism Dilemma Occur and Be Corrected?
基层是服务群众和政策执行的终端末梢,但陷入了形式主义困局.基层形式主义与政策执行过程中的模糊性和冲突性密切相关,不同程度的模糊性和冲突性及其组合对应不同的政策执行样态,背后是不同的支配性因素,反映不同的形式主义表征."行政性执行"因资源约束导致应对乏力的形式主义,"政治性执行"因权力约束导致对标对表的形式主义,"实验性执行"因信息约束导致茫然探索的形式主义,"象征性执行"因综合约束导致互惠合谋的形式主义.根源在于"基层资源"在僵化科层制中的支撑乏力,"上级权力"在高度冲突性中的刚性运行,"基层情境"在高度模糊性中的作为驱动,"地方合作"在高模糊冲突中的不当默会.矫治基层形式主义,要夯实基层资源,适配更为务实的科层运行;调适上级权力,实施低冲突化的激励约束;解析基层情境,培育低模糊化的基层空间;规范地方合作,构建清晰协同的基层生态.
The grassroots is the terminal of serving the public and policy implementation,but cur-rently caught in a formalist dilemma.Grass-roots formalism is closely related to ambiguity and con-flict in policy implementation.Different degrees of ambiguity and conflict and their combinations correspond to different policy implementation paradigms,behind which are different dominant fac-tors reflecting different formalist representations.In the implementation of the policy of contracted services for family doctors,"administrative implementation"has led to formalism of weak response due to resource constraints,"political implementation"has led to the formalism of benchmarking due to power constraints,"experimental implementation"has led to the formalism of confused ex-ploration due to information constraints,and"symbolic implementation"has led to the formalism of reciprocal collusion due to integrative constraints.The root of the problem lies in the lack of sup-port for"grass-roots resources"in a rigid hierarchical system,the rigidity of"superior power"in a high degree of conflict,the driving force of"grass-roots situations"in a high degree of ambiguity,and the inappropriate acquiescence of"local co-operation"in a high degree of ambiguous conflict.In order to correct grass-roots formalism,we should strengthen grass-roots resources and adapt a more pragmatic section operation,adjust superior power and implement low-conflict incentives and con-straints,analyze the grass-roots situation and cultivate a low-ambiguity grass-roots space,regulate local co-operation and build a clear and synergistic grass-roots ecology.
王春城;苏菲
燕山大学公共管理学院,河北秦皇岛 066004||河北省高校人文社科重点研究基地——燕山大学县域振兴发展政策研究中心,河北秦皇岛 066004燕山大学公共管理学院,河北秦皇岛 066004
政治法律
基层形式主义模糊性冲突性政策执行
grass-roots formalismambiguityconflictpolicy implementation
《中共天津市委党校学报》 2024 (003)
50-62 / 13
本文为国家社科基金一般项目"巩固拓展脱贫攻坚成果的政策供给及系统治理机制研究"(21BZZ057)的阶段性研究成果.
评论