基于实物期权的林业碳汇项目价值评估OA北大核心CHSSCDCSTPCD
The Value Evaluation of Forestry Carbon Sinks Projects Based on Real Options
应用实物期权理论,剖析林业碳汇项目的价值构成,构建以实物期权理论为基础的林业碳汇项目价值评估模型,以兴安盟阿尔山人工造林建设项目为研究对象,通过实证数值评估项目的实际价值,探讨木材价格、碳汇价格等影响因素的变化对项目价值的影响.结果表明:林业碳汇项目的价值涵盖了林木资产价值、碳汇资产价值和投入成本等多个方面,林木资产与碳汇资产的价值会随市场波动而变化,分别产生一定的期权价值,因此在进行林业碳汇项目的整体价值评估时,必须充分考虑两者各自的期权价值;木材价格和碳汇价格对项目价值有正面影响,而无风险利率对项目价值有负面影响.最后,结合碳汇交易政策和林业碳汇发展现状,提出鼓励林业碳汇发展和增强林业碳汇项目社会效益的政策建议.
⑴Background——Forest management has become one of the important means to alleviate environmental problems because of its economic and ecological benefits.The commercial value of traditional forestry projects is limited,while the income from carbon sinks trading becomes the main growth point of forestry economic benefits.However,forestry carbon sinks projects have long operating cycle,strong policy and complex value evaluation.It is difficult to describe the value of forestry carbon sinks by traditional evaluation methods,but the real option theory is more suitable for evaluating the comprehensive value of forestry carbon sinks.Compared with the B-S model,the binary tree model is more consistent with the phased and periodic characteristics of forestry carbon sinks. ⑵ Methods——Based on the real optiontheory,this paper first analyzed the option characteristics of forest-ry carbon sinks project,revealed the value composition of forestry carbon sinks project,and established the value evaluation model of forestry carbon sinks project based on the binary tree model.Then,the carbon sinks afforesta-tion project in Arshaan City of Hinggan League of Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region was selected as the re-search object to evaluate the practical value of the project.Finally,the sensitivity analysis was used to analyze the impact of timber price,carbon price and risk-free interest rate on the project value. ⑶ Results——First,forestry carbon sinks project has option characteristics,and the real option theory can evaluate the potential value brought by uncertainty.The value of forestry carbon sinks project consists of three parts:forest assets value,carbon sinks assets value and option strike price.The fluctuation of forest assets and car-bon sinks assets will bring their respective option values.Second,the overall value of the project under different e-valuation models is significantly different.In the NPV model,when the project is developed as a general afforesta-tion project,the net income is -9.102 1 million yuan,the unit economic income is -2 068.65 yuan/hm2,and the project is a loss.When the project is developed as a carbon sinks afforestation project,the net income is 297,900 yuan,the unit economic income is 67.70 yuan/hm2,and the carbon sinks income increases the income of the project.In the real option model,the value of forest assets is 163.709 2 million yuan,the value of carbon sinks as-sets is 18.892 6 million yuan,the total value of the project is 81.452 2 million yuan,and the unit economic bene-fit is 18,511.87 yuan/hm2.The option value of forest assets and carbon sinks assets significantly improves the project efficiency.Third,in the sensitivity analysis,timber price and carbon sinks price have a positive impact on the project value,while the risk-free interestrate has a negative impact on the project value. ⑷ Conclusions and Discussions——Based on the above conclusions,the following policy suggestions are put forward:First,strengthen the application of the real option method in the actual evaluation of the value of for-estry carbon sinks projects,improve the evaluation mechanism of forestry carbon sinks projects,fully consider the option value of projects when the evaluation returns are negative by using the traditional method,and consider the opportunity value brought by fluctuation in the riskier market environment.Second,make full use of uncertainties in forestry carbon sinks projects.At the individual level,encourage the forest farmers to carry out carbon sinks af-forestation projects,help them realize the diversified value of carbon sinks afforestation projects,and further stim-ulate the willingness of the forest farmers to participate.At the market level,guide multiple entities to participate in the implementation of forestry carbon sinks projects,and strengthen the understanding of the market and busi-ness entities on the forestry carbon sinks trading.Third,improve the trading mechanism of forest resources,deeply explore the market system of carbon sinks trading,guide the benign fluctuations of timber prices and carbon sinks prices,further enhance the social benefits of forestry carbon sinks projects,and properly regulate the risk-free in-terest rate,reduce the market access threshold,and improve the ecological compensation mechanism.
徐玥;张绍文
北京林业大学 经济管理学院,北京 100083
经济学
林业碳汇价值评估实物期权二叉树模型
forestry carbon sinksvalue evaluationreal optionbinary tree model
《林业经济问题》 2024 (002)
171-178 / 8
评论