网湖放养与池塘养殖鳙的肌肉品质比较分析OA北大核心CSTPCD
Comparative study on the muscle quality of Hypophthalmichthys nobilis between Wanghu Lake and its surrounding ponds
为探究大水面养殖与池塘养殖模式下鱼类肌肉品质可能存在的差异及其原因,以鳙(Hypophthalmichthys nobilis)为研究对象,采集并观测湖北省网湖(网湖放养组)和周边养殖池塘(池塘养殖组)两组鳙的背部肌肉的表观、质构、营养和风味等特征,并对两者的水质条件与饵料生物组成进行对比研究.结果显示:(1)网湖放养鳙的腹脂比(IPF)、肝体比(HSI)显著低于池塘养殖组(P<0.05),而两者的肥满度(CF)和脏体比(VSI)无显著差异(P>0.05);网湖放养鳙的背部鱼皮和背部鱼肉的亮度值(L*)和白度值(W)显著高于池塘养殖组(P<0.05);(2)网湖放养鳙肌肉的弹性、内聚性高于池塘养殖组(P>0.05),硬度显著低于池塘养殖组(P<0.05);(3)网湖放养鳙的水分、粗蛋白含量显著低于池塘养殖组(P<0.05),而粗脂肪含量显著高于池塘养殖组(P<0.05);网湖放养鳙的必需氨基酸含量及其评分显著高于池塘养殖组(P<0.05);网湖放养组和池塘养殖组的EAA/TAA比值分别为 41.24%、40.84%,EAA/NEAA的比值分别为 84.18%、83.03%,均符合FAO/WHO理想模式标准;网湖放养组的单不饱和脂肪酸、多不饱和脂肪酸均显著高于池塘养殖组(P<0.05);网湖放养鳙肌肉中Ca、Zn的含量高于池塘养殖组(P>0.05);(4)网湖放养组的鲜味氨基酸占比更高,苦味氨基酸占比更低;网湖放养组和池塘养殖组的最高气味活度值分别是呈青草味的己醛和油脂味的 1-辛醛,对气味呈负面影响的 1-己醇、3-戊酮等挥发性化合物含量及相对气味活度值(ROAV)在网湖放养组更低.研究结果表明,网湖放养鳙相对于池塘养殖组具有更好的形态特征、肌肉营养和风味品质,这与其养殖环境和天然饵料的差异有关.本研究可为大水面生态渔业的发展提供理论参考.
To investigate potential variances in fish muscle quality under different culture modes and their causes,this study focused on the bighead carp(Hypophthalmichthys nobilis)as a target object.Samples were collected and observed in the Wanghu Lake(Wanghu Lake stocking group)and the surrounding culture ponds(pond culture group)in Hubei Province.The appearance,texture,nutritional value,and flavor characteristics of the back muscles of the two groups of bighead carp were compared.Additionally,the water quality and feed biological composition of the two groups were compared.Results showed that:(1)The intraperitoneal fat(IPF)and hepatopancreas somatic indices(HSI)of bighead carp raised in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were significantly lower than those in the pond culture group(P<0.05).However,there was no significant difference between the two groups in terms of condition factor(CF)and viscerosomatic index(VSI)(P>0.05).The luminance value(L*)and whiteness value(W)of back skin and meat of bighead carp in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were significantly higher than those in the pond culture group(P<0.05).(2)The elasticity and cohesion of the bighead carp muscles in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were higher than those in the pond culture group(P>0.05),whereas hardness was significantly lower than that in the pond culture group(P<0.05).(3)The water and crude protein content of bighead carps in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were significantly lower than those in the pond culture group(P<0.05).The crude fat content was significantly higher than that in the pond culture group(P<0.05).The essential amino acid content and score of bighead carp in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were significantly higher than those in the pond culture group(P<0.05).The essential amino acid(EAA)/toal amino acid(TAA)values of the Wanghu Lake stocking and pond culture groups were 41.24%and 40.84%,the ratio of EAA/nonessential amino acid(NEAA)was 84.18%and 83.03%,respectively,meeting the FAO/WHO ideal model standards.However,the levels of monounsaturated and polyunsaturated fatty acids in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were significantly higher than those in the pond culture group(P<0.05).The concentrations of Ca and Zn in the muscles of bighead carp in the Wanghu Lake stocking group were higher than those in the pond culture group(P>0.05).(4)The proportion of fresh amino acids was higher and the proportion of bitter amino acids was lower in the Wanghu Lake stocking group.The highest odor activity values were observed for the grassy odor hexanal and fatty odor 1-octanal in the Wanghu Lake stocking and pond culture groups,respectively.Additionally,the content of volatile compounds such as 1-hexanol and 3-pentanone in the Wanghu Lake stocking group was lower than that in the pond culture group,and the relative odor activity value(ROAV)of these volatile compounds in the pond culture group was lower than that in the pond culture group.The results showed that bighead carp reared in the Wanghu Lake stocking group had better morphological characteristics,muscle nutrition,and flavor quality than those reared in the pond culture group,associated with differences between the culture environment and natural bait.The conclusions of this study provide a theoretical reference for the development of large-scale ecological fisheries.
王森;马吉顺;钟可儿;熊浩;周琼
华中农业大学水产学院,湖北 武汉 430070||长江经济带大宗水生生物产业绿色发展教育部工程研究中心,湖北 武汉 430070
水产学
鳙大水面养殖湖泊放养池塘养殖营养品质水质分析饵料组成
Hypophthalmichthys nobilislarge surface culturelake stockingpond culturenutritional qualitywater quality analysisbait composition
《中国水产科学》 2024 (005)
557-575 / 19
国家重点研发计划重点专项(2019YFD0900601-02);中央高校基本科研业务费专项资金资助项目(2662020SCPY007).
评论