有机无机配施对新植甘蔗生产影响的Meta分析OA
Meta-analysis of the Effects of Combined Application of Organic and Inorganic Fertilizers on the Production of Plant Crop in Sugarcane
[目的]通过整合前人研究结果进行定量分析,为甘蔗绿色施肥及高效生产提供参考.[方法]基于中国知网,万方数据和Web of Science数据库,以"甘蔗""产量"和"有机肥"等为关键词相互组合后进行文献检索,并提取相应数据.采用Meta分析方法,以单施化肥处理为对照,选择反应比作为效应值,整合分析有机无机配施对新植甘蔗生产的综合影响,及影响甘蔗产量效应的因素.[结果]有机无机配施能显著提高新植甘蔗的农艺性状、产量和蔗糖分,其中甘蔗产量和蔗糖分的增长率(Z)分别为 10.72%和 2.33%.2003-2023 年,有机无机配施对甘蔗的增产效应显著;除了云南蔗区,其余4 省(自治区)蔗区甘蔗增产效应显著;有机无机配施在 5 种常见蔗田土壤中均对甘蔗表现出显著的增产效应,且土壤pH和肥力越低,增产效果越显著.在 5 个中国大陆主栽甘蔗品种中,有机无机配施对'云蔗 08-1609'的增产效应最高(Z=22.94%),对'新台糖 22 号'的增产效应最低(Z=7.99%);动物源有机肥与化肥配施对甘蔗的增产效应(Z=13.13%)要优于植物源有机肥与化肥配施(Z=11.48%);有机无机配施对甘蔗的增产效应随种植行距和无机氮肥施用量的增加呈增长趋势,当种植行距>1.15 m,无机氮肥施用量>300 kg/hm2 时甘蔗的增产效应达到最高,分别为Z=15.79%、Z=13.62%.[结论]有机无机配施能够显著提高新植甘蔗的农艺性状与经济性状,是一种高效的施肥技术.同时,有机无机配施对新植甘蔗的增产效应受种植年份、种植区域、土壤类型和理化性质、种植品种和栽培措施的显著影响,需要因地制宜地制定栽培管理策略.
[Objective]Quantitative analysis was carried out by integrating the results of previous studies to provide insights into green fertilization and efficient production of sugarcane.[Methods]Based on CNKI,Wanfang data and Web of Science database,this paper selected'sugarcane','yield'and'organic fertilizer'as keywords to combine each other for literature retrieval and corresponding data extraction.Meta-analysis method was used to analyze the comprehensive effect of organic and inorganic combined application on sugarcane yield of plant crop and the factors affecting the yield effect,with single chemical fertilizer treatment as the control and response ratio as the effect value.[Results]The combined application of organic fertilizer and inorganic fertilizer could significantly improve the agronomic traits,yield and sucrose content of plant crop in sugarcane.The growth rates(Z)of sugarcane yield and sucrose content were 10.72%and 2.33%,respectively.From 2003 to 2023,the combined application of organic and inorganic fertilizers had a significant effect on the increase of sugarcane yield.Except for Yunnan sugarcane region,the yield-increasing effect of sugarcane in the other four provinces(autonomous regions)was significant.The combined application of organic and inorganic fertilizers showed a significant yield-increasing effect on sugarcane in five common sugarcane fields,and the lower the soil fertility and soil pH,the more significant the yield-increasing effect.Among the five main sugarcane varieties in mainland China,the combined application of organic and inorganic fertilizers had the highest yield-increasing effect on Yunzhe 081609(Z=22.94%)and the lowest yield-increasing effect on XTT22(Z=7.99%).The yield-increasing effect of animal-derived organic fertilizer combined with chemical fertilizer on sugarcane(Z=13.13%)was better than plant-derived organic fertilizer combined with chemical fertilizer(Z=11.48%).The yield-increasing effect of combined application of organic and inorganic fertilizers on sugarcane showed an increasing trend with the increase of planting spacing and inorganic nitrogen fertilizer input,respectively.The yield-increasing effect of sugarcane reached the highest(Z=15.79%,Z=13.62%)when the planting row spacing was greater than 1.15 m and the inorganic nitrogen fertilizer input was greater than 300 kg/hm2,respectively.[Conclusion]The combined application of organic fertilizer and inorganic fertilizer can significantly improve the agronomic and economic traits of sugarcane from plant crop,which is an efficient fertilization technology.At the same time,the yield-increasing effect of combined application of organic fertilizer and inorganic fertilizer on sugarcane plant crop is significantly affected by planting year,planting area,soil type and physical and chemical properties,varieties and cultivation practices,so it is necessary to formulate cultivation management strategies according to local conditions.
周健平;韦慧明;杨业彬;邓思;覃耀冠;苏小茴;何可;韦开军
广西壮族自治区农业科学院柳州分院/柳州市农业科学研究中心,广西柳州 545000
农业科学
甘蔗有机无机配施Meta分析产量
sugarcanecombinative application of organic and inorganic fertilizersMeta-analysisyield
《中国糖料》 2024 (004)
78-90 / 13
广西科技重大专项(桂科AA22117002-7);国家现代农业产业技术体系广西甘蔗创新团队建设项目(nycytxgxcxtd-2021-03-05)资助.
评论