益气维血联合铁剂对比生血宝联合铁剂治疗贫血相关疾病的临床疗效OACSTPCD
Clinical efficacy comparison of Yiqiweixue combined with iron supplement and Sheng-shuibao combined with iron supplement in treatment of anemia-related diseases
目的 对比益气维血片/胶囊联合铁剂与生血宝合剂/颗粒联合铁剂治疗贫血相关疾病的临床疗效.方法 选取2019-2021 年全国 6 省市 10 家综合医院信息系统数据库中,接受诊疗超过 1 年的贫血相关疾病患者 916 例,根据治疗方法不同分为观察组和对照组,观察组采用益气维血片/胶囊联合铁剂>30 d(n=514),对照组采用生血宝合剂/颗粒联合铁剂>30 d(n=402),采用倾向性评分匹配(PSM)方法平衡观察组和对照组的基线特征,每组 205 例.有效性指标为治愈率[患者血红蛋白(Hb)恢复正常 1 年的累计发生率]、有效率(Hb上升>10 g/L 1 年的累计发生率)、Hb恢复正常中位时间及Hb上升>10 g/L中位时间;安全性指标为肝功能ALT、AST前后变化.结果 两组治愈率均为44.39%,无统计学差异;观察组有效率明显高于对照组(67.32%vs.54.63%,P<0.01);两组中位Hb恢复正常时间、中位Hb上升>10 g/L时间均相当,均未观察到中位复发时间.两组的ALT、AST值与用药前相比均无明显上升(P>0.05).结论 两组治愈率、治愈和起效时间无差别,具有较好的安全性,益气维血有效率显著优于生血宝,具有临床推广价值.
Objective To compare the clinical efficacy of Yiqiweixue tablets/capsules combined with iron supplements and Shengxuebao combination/granules combined with iron supplements in the treatment of anemia-related diseases.Methods A total of 916 patients with anemia-related diseases who had received treatment of Yiqiweixue(n=514)and Shengxuebao(n=402)for more than 1 year were selected from the information system database of 10 general hospitals in 6 provinces and cities across China from 2019 to 2021.Propensity score matching(PSM)method was used to balance the baseline characters of the observation and control group.After PSM,205 cases the observation group of Yiqiweixue tablets/capsules combined with iron for>30 days,while the control group of Shengxuebao combination/granules combined with iron for>30 days.The effectiveness indicators included cure rate(the cumulative incidence rate of patients whose hemoglobin(Hb)levels return to normal within one year),and efficacy rate(the cumulative incidence rate of patients whose Hb levels increase by more than 10g/L within one year),median time for Hb to return to normal and median time for Hb increase of more than 10 g/L.Safety indicators were changes of liver function ALT and AST.Results The cure rates of the two groups were 44.39%,with no statistically significant difference;the efficacy rate of the observation group was significantly higher than that of the control group(67.32%vs.54.63%,P<0.01);both the median time for Hb to return to normal and the median time for Hb to increase by more than 10 g/L were not significantly different in two groups,and no median relapse time was observed.The ALT and AST values in both groups showed no significant increase after treatment(P>0.05).Conclusions There is no difference in cure rate,time to cure and onset of actio between the 2 groups.Both treatments showed no impacts on liver function,but Yiqiweixue has sig-nificantly higher effective rate than Shengxuebao,which can be recommended for clinical use.
曹琰;于梦洋;金德奎;杨姗姗;钟立胜;郑姣;张承英
100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科100039 北京,解放军总医院第三医学中心全科医学科
临床医学
益气维血生血宝铁剂贫血相关疾病
YiqiweixueShengxuebaoiron supplementanemia-related diseases
《武警医学》 2024 (11)
948-951,955,5
评论