运筹与管理2024，Vol.33Issue(9)：36-41,6.DOI:10.12005/orms.2024.0282
政府信息优势下处置街头暴力事件的信号博弈模型
Signal Game Model of Controlling Street Violence under the Government Information Superiority
摘要
Abstract
In dealing with street violence,the government holds an information advantage.This paper studies how the government can utilize this advantage to signal public security budgets to induce rioters to surrender,and achieving the goal of stopping violence and restoring order.Street violence incidents are characterized by informa-tion asymmetry,antagonistic contradictions,phased developments,and zero-sum games between parties.It is crucial for governments to mobilize resources effectively under full intelligence information to curb violence and restore order.This paper constructs a two-stage signaling game model to analyze the government's optimal strike strategies under different budget scenarios.The model assumes that the government has complete information while rioters have incomplete information,and considers that the government's public security budget is finite.The study shows that when the rioters'expected cost of surrender is less than the loss from government strikes,their optimal strategy is to surrender in the first stage;when the expected losses are low,they tend to resist until the end.If the government has a sufficient budget,it needs to send a signal in the first stage by investing resources greater than the cost of surrender,forcing rioters to surrender in the first stage;otherwise,the govern-ment with a smaller budget needs to invest all its resources in the first stage to combat rioters. This paper uses the 2019 Hong Kong"anti-extradition bill"incident as a case study to validate the model's effectiveness.In the Hong Kong"anti-extradition bill"incident,the rioters updated their beliefs about the government's initial and remaining resources after observing the government's first-stage resource investment,and decided whether to surrender.The results show that when rioters expect the government budget to be suffi-cient,they will choose to surrender in the first stage;when the expected government budget is insufficient,they will choose to continue resisting.Through the case analysis,the study finds that the government can effectively force rioters to surrender by sending a signal in the first stage with resources greater than the cost of surrender,achieving the goal of stopping violence and restoring order. The findings of this study provide important insights for governments in handling street violence incidents and managing prolonged conflicts.The paper assumes that the remaining resources will not change in the second stage,i.e.,the total resources invested in by the government remain unchanged.In future research,changes in the second stage government resources can be considered for a more in-depth analysis.This paper focuses on the game between the government and rioters under the information advantage,not considering other actors such as social groups,NGOs,and the public,who may potentially become rioters under certain conditions.Future research could incorporate these potential rioters into the model analysis.Additionally,combining smart city big data for precise situational awareness with numerical analysis could lead to more targeted conclusions. Overall,this paper systematically analyzes how the government can effectively handle street violence incidents by signaling public security budgets under an information advantage,providing theoretical and practical guidance for governments worldwide.关键词
街头暴力事件/信号博弈/止暴治乱策略/信息优势/公共安全预算Key words
street violence/signal game/strategy to stop violence and disorder/information advantage/public security budget分类
管理科学引用本文复制引用
刘德海,金豫,逯彩云,刘其琛..政府信息优势下处置街头暴力事件的信号博弈模型[J].运筹与管理,2024,33(9):36-41,6.基金项目
国家自然科学基金资助项目(72274030,71874024) （72274030,71874024）
