信息资源管理学报2024，Vol.14Issue(6)：99-115,17.DOI:10.13365/j.jirm.2024.06.099
基于相对引用方法的微信提及指标标准化研究
A Study on the Standardization of WeChat Mention Metrics Based on Relative Citation Methods
摘要
Abstract
The standardization of altmetrics indicators is a crucial requirement for their application in sci-entific evaluation.This study targets the construction of a Chinese indigenous knowledge system,which focu-ses on WeChat mention data from Chinese academic papers.We used standardization methods based on rel-ative citation methods and incorporated the WeChat Communication Index to establish standardized metrics for WeChat mentions.This research aims to provide relevant references and foundations for the develop-ment,deepening,and application of Chinese altmetrics data sources.Key findings include:(1)By elimina-ting time differences,disciplinary variations,high sparsity,and skewed distributions in WeChat mention metrics,the standardized indicators for WeChat mentions can be considered for application in academic e-valuation and social impact assessment.(2)Within the WI(WeChat Index)journal set,philosophy and hu-manities,engineering Ⅱ,and agricultural engineering are the top three disciplines with the highest number of WeChat mentions of academic papers.(3)WPP/FWSm and MNWS,metrics based on WeChat mention fre-quency,show minimal differences.These two indexes are suitable for evaluating WeChat attention at the level of individual papers and journals but are unsuitable for evaluating universities due to their influence by the distribution characteristics of WeChat mentions.(4)Standardized metrics,WCPP/FWSm and MNWC,incorporating WeChat influence indices,show a better balance between WeChat influence and mention vol-ume.They demonstrate robustness and prove valuable for assessing WeChat attention at the individual pa-per,journal,and university levels.They are more effective in assessing the WeChat attention and the dis-semination impact of academic papers in universities.关键词
替代计量学/微信公众号/替代计量指标/微信提及/指标标准化Key words
Altmetrics/WeChat official account/Altmetrics indicators/WeChat mention/Metric stand-ardization分类
社会科学引用本文复制引用
李龙飞,余厚强,杨思洛..基于相对引用方法的微信提及指标标准化研究[J].信息资源管理学报,2024,14(6):99-115,17.基金项目
本文系国家自然科学基金面上项目"中国替代计量的数据识别机制与关键分析方法研究"(72274227)和广东省社会科学基金项目"标准化替代计量指标的构建方案与实证研究"(GD23YTS04)的研究成果之一.(This is an outcome of the project"Study of Data Identification Mechanism and Key Analytical Methods for Chinese Altmetrics"(72274227)supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China,and the project"Construction Method and Em-pirical Study of Normalizing Altmetric Indicators"(GD23YTS04)supported by the Social Science Foundation of Guangdong Province,China.) （72274227）
