经锁骨下入路与胸前入路腔镜手术治疗甲状腺癌的疗效比较OACSTPCD
Comparative effectiveness research of endoscopic surgery via subclavian approach and anterior thoracic approach in the treatment of thyroid cancer
目的:比较经锁骨下入路与胸前入路腔镜手术治疗甲状腺癌的临床效果.方法:回顾分析 2021 年 1 月至 2023年9 月行经锁骨下入路(锁骨下组)与胸前入路(胸前组)腔镜手术的80 例甲状腺癌患者的临床资料,其中男20 例,女60 例,平均(31.86±6.98)岁,每组40 例.结果:两组均顺利完成腔镜手术,无中转开放手术.锁骨下组手术时间短于胸前组[(114.43±18.58)min vs.(165.88±26.70)min,t=-5.042,P<0.001],中央区完全暴露率高于胸前组(97.50%vs.85.00%,χ2=9.347,P=0.033),胸前组手术切口总长度短于锁骨下组[(2.32±0.11)cm vs.(4.41±0.09)cm,t=132.952,P<0.001],两组患者满意度评分差异无统计学意义[(8.90±0.38)vs.(9.40±0.50),t=1.561,P=0.087].结论:经锁骨下入路腔镜手术中央区完全暴露率更高,手术时间更短,具有较好的临床应用价值.
Objective:To compare the clinical effect of endoscopic surgery via subclavian approach and anterior thoracic approach in the treatment of thyroid cancer.Methods:The clinical data of 80 patients with thyroid cancer who underwent subclavian and anterior thoracic endoscopic thyroidectomy from Jan.2021 to Sep.2023 were retrospectively analyzed.There were 40 cases in each group,including20 malesand60 females,aged(31.86±6.98)years.Results:All operations were successfully completed under laparoscopy without conversion to open surgery.Compared with the anterior thoracic group,the operation time of subclavian group was shorter[(114.43±18.58)min vs.(165.88±26.70)min,t=-5.042,P<0.001],the complete exposure rate of central area was higher(97.50%vs.85.00%,χ2=9.347,P=0.033).The total length of incision was shorter in anterior thoracic group than that in subclavian group[(2.32±0.11)cm vs.(4.41±0.09)cm,t=132.952,P<0.001].There was no significant difference in patients'satisfaction scores between the two groups[(8.90±0.38)vs.(9.40±0.50),t=1.561,P=0.087].Conclusions:Subclavian endoscopic thyroidectomy has higher central area exposure rate and shorter operation time.It is suitable for some thyroid cancer patients with cosmetic needs and has good clinical application value.
张传灼;芮强
江苏省中医院普外科,江苏 南京,210001江苏省中医院普外科,江苏 南京,210001
临床医学
甲状腺肿瘤甲状腺切除术内窥镜检查经锁骨下入路胸前入路疗效比较研究
Thyroid neoplasmsThyroidectomyEndoscopySubclavian approachAnterior chest approachComparative effec-tiveness research
《腹腔镜外科杂志》 2024 (11)
801-805,5
江苏省中医院科技项目(Y20009)
评论