中国沼气2025，Vol.43Issue(1)：35-44,10.DOI:10.20022/j.cnki.1000-1166.2025010035
水稻秸秆不同预处理方式对沼气产量影响的Meta分析
Meta-analysis of Different Pretreatment Methods on Biogas Production from Rice Straw
摘要
Abstract
This research is to analyze quantitatively the effects of pretreatment methods on biogas production from rice straw,so as to clarify the effects of different pretreatment methods,which could provide reference for a more suitable and effective pretreatment method.A meta-analysis was performed to search and screen the published literatures about the effects of different pretreatment methods on biogas production from rice straw in Chinese document databases,and the data-base included 54 related studies and 565 pairs of experiment data.The results showed that:1)compared with no pretreat-ment,the effect size(SMD)of physical pretreatment was 1.27,the differences were extremely significant(p＜0.0001);the effect size(SMD)of chemical pretreatment was 2.05,the differences were extremely significant(p＜0.00001);the effect size(SMD)of biological pretreatment was 1.00,the differences were significant(p＜0.05);the effect size(SMD)of combined pretreatment was 4.29,the differences were extremely significant(p＜0.00001).The effect order of 4 differ-ent pretreament methods was Combined＞Chemical＞Physical＞Biological.2)the chemical pretreatment methods were di-vided into 3 subgroups,acidic and other chemical pretreatment.The effect order of 3 subgroups was alkaline＞acidic＞other chemical pretreatment.The pretreatment remarkably promoted the biogas production of rice straw,the combined pretreat-ment method was the most effective method.In the future,combined pretreatment methods such as physical pretreatment and chemical pretreatment combined with microbial pretreatment will become the dominant pre treatment mode.关键词
Meta分析/水稻秸秆/预处理/沼气产量Key words
Meta-analysis/rice straw/pretreatment/biogas production分类
农业科技引用本文复制引用
宋贤冲,刘军,柯琴,黄华杰,毛纯,杨敏旋,赵隽宇,蒋湖波,唐健..水稻秸秆不同预处理方式对沼气产量影响的Meta分析[J].中国沼气,2025,43(1):35-44,10.基金项目
广西科技计划项目(桂科AD23049001) （桂科AD23049001）
广西林科院研究团队项目(2024RT13) （2024RT13）
广西自筹经费林业科技项目(2323GXZCLK57) （2323GXZCLK57）
广西农村能源科技项目(GXNCNY2023KJ-01). （GXNCNY2023KJ-01）
