财政透明度与企业避税行为OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCICSTPCD
Fiscal transparency and corporate tax avoidance
财政透明度是各级政府维持运行效率和接受社会监督的重要制度保证.以我国 2014-2019 年 A 股上市公司作为研究样本,本文实证研究了宏观财政透明度对微观企业避税行为的影响.研究发现:地方政府财政透明度的提升能够有效增加上市公司的主动避税程度.机制检验显示,主结果是由高财政透明度提升财政支出效率和降低财政压力引起的.进一步分析表明:主结果只在民营、高融资约束和有违规记录的子样本中显著,且在政府公共服务支出较高、税收征管强度较低、营商环境较好和市场竞争程度较强的地区作用更强.研究结论丰富了对财政透明度的微观经济后果的认识,进一步拓展了企业避税行为的影响因素分析边界,为充分发挥财政透明的宏微观治理作用以及完善政府财政支出制度建设提供了政策建议.
Fiscal transparency reflects the degree of government's disclosure on fiscal funds.It can effectively improve the efficiency and honesty of government operation,reduce the possible abuse of fiscal funds,and restrain inefficient investment behaviors such as idle funds by exerting the role of public supervision.Extant studies on fiscal transparency mainly focuses on the level of government and region.Few types of research intensely discuss the influence of fiscal transparency,a macro-institutional factor,on micro-economic subjects such as enterprises.Correspondingly,tax behavior is an important bridge connecting the relationship between enterprises and government and an essential manifestation of macro-system influencing enterprise behavior.At the same time,as a critical factor affecting the business development of enterprises,tax evasion can not only bring direct cash inflow and performance benefits to enterprises,but also produce a specific reputation loss risk and administrative penalty cost.Therefore,based on the above analysis,this paper believes that it is of high academic value to explore the macro-influencing factors of corporate tax avoidance behavior. To further explore the micro-economic consequences of local government fiscal transparency,this paper selects non-financial listed companies in China's A-share market from 2014 to 2019 as research samples to empirically test the impact of fiscal transparency on corporate tax avoidance.The data of fiscal transparency comes from the Research Report on Fiscal Transparency of Chinese Municipal Governments released by the School of Public Administration of Tsinghua University,which evaluates the information disclosure of local governments in terms of the organization setting and budget disclosure.The higher the score is,the higher the fiscal transparency is.This paper puts forward two influence paths in the opposite direction based on the existing research conclusions.Path 1 argues that the improvement of prefectural government fiscal transparency,on the one hand,can improve local fiscal expenditure efficiency and reduce the fiscal pressure to minimize enterprises'total potential future earnings of paying taxes,on the other hand,can improve the local business environment to attract foreign investment and increase the intensity of competition in the market,both could encourage companies to adopt a more positive tax avoidance.Path 2 believes that the improvement of government fiscal transparency will improve the willingness of enterprises to comply with tax by increasing government integrity;meanwhile,the restraint of fiscal fund discipline can promote the government to enforce tax strictly,thus reducing the degree of corporate tax avoidance. The empirical results support the positive path.The improvement of government fiscal transparency significantly increases RATE,which is equal to the difference between the nominal tax rate and the effective tax rate,also indicates the increase of enterprises'subjectively tax avoidance behavior.Mechanism tests show that fiscal expenditure efficiency and fiscal pressure mediate this process,and the path of fiscal transparency influencing corporate tax avoidance behavior through the intensity of market competition and tax administration is not found.After using mineral resource dependence and Bartik as instrumental variables to control endogenous,using the budget and budget implementation score in the fiscal transparency score system to replace the independent variable,using effective tax rate of enterprises(ETR),book-tax differences(BTD),and fixed effect residual of BTD(DDBTD)to replace the dependent variable,and using the propensity score matching(PSM)method,the main results remain the same and show solid robustness. Further results in cross-sectional tests show that:At the corporate level,private enterprises are weaker than state-owned enterprises in market competition and financing channels,high financing constrained enterprises have a higher demand for cash flow and performance profits,and enterprises with violation records have higher tendency of opportunism.Therefore,the impact of fiscal transparency on enterprise tax avoidance is more substantial in these kinds of enterprises.At the regional level,high public service expenditure accounts for a lower operating efficiency of regional governments,which makes the improvement of fiscal transparency play a more vital role in improving efficiency,and the advancement of enterprise tax avoidance is more significant;The intensity of tax collection and management reflects the government's inspection of enterprise tax avoidance,so the impact of fiscal transparency on enterprise tax avoidance is weaker in areas with higher law enforcement intensity;In regions with better business environment and higher competition,the cost and demand of tax avoidance is also stronger,leading to a more significant role of fiscal transparency. In summary,this paper focuses on the impact of the macro phenomenon of government fiscal transparency on the micro behavior of corporate tax behavior,which fills the gap in the field of microeconomic consequences of fiscal transparency and further enriches the research on the macro influencing factors of corporate tax behavior,has specific theoretical significance and contribution.At the same time,at the practice level,the research conclusion is helpful to guide the local governments at all levels to continue deepening fiscal information transparency,help enterprises to adjust the allocation of resources,including tax policy.It can also provide a specific theoretical basis and practical guidance for researching the macro and micro governance role of government information disclosure,promoting a clean and efficient fiscal system and a healthy relationship between government and enterprises,and encouraging the rational allocation of enterprise resources.
田高良;刘晓丰;司毅
西安交通大学 管理学院/国家级管理实验教学示范中心,陕西 西安 710049
经济学
财政透明企业避税财政支出效率财政压力
Fiscal transparencyCorporate tax avoidanceFiscal expenditure efficiencyFiscal pressure
《管理工程学报》 2024 (003)
58-75 / 18
国家自然科学基金项目(72002165、71672141);教育部人文社会科学基金项目(20YJC790116) The National Natural Science Foundation of China(72002165,71672141);The Social Science Foundation of The Chinese Education Commission(20YJC790216)
评论