|国家科技期刊平台
首页|期刊导航|河北法学|行政公益诉讼诉前检察建议与诉讼请求关系研究

行政公益诉讼诉前检察建议与诉讼请求关系研究OA北大核心CHSSCDCSSCI

Research on the Relationship between Administrative Public Interest Litigation Pre-litigation Procuratorial Suggestions and Litigation Claims

中文摘要英文摘要

正确界定诉前检察建议与诉讼请求的关系是厘清诉前程序与诉讼程序关系、完善行政公益诉讼制度的必然要求.现阶段,《人民检察院公益诉讼办案规则》第75条虽然已将诉前检察建议与诉讼请求的关系规定为一种"衔接"关系,但由于法律规定模糊、理论研究滞后,理论界与实务界对于二者的目的是否完全一致、二者的精准程度是否完全等同以及如何理解二者在逻辑上的衔接性等问题,认识并不一致,严重影响了司法的规范性.为此,应以目的理论、法律监督理论以及诉前程序与诉讼程序关系理论等为依据,从程序目的、检察机关的法律职能以及诉前程序与诉讼程序的关系等层面出发,对二者的目的、精准程度以及逻辑关系等进行全方位剖析.

Correctly defining the relationship between pre-litigation procuratorial recommendations and litigation claims is an inevitable requirement for clarifying the relationship between pre-litigation procedures and litigation procedures and improving the administrative public interest litigation system.At this stage,Article 75 of the Rules for Public Interest Litigation of the People's Procuratorate has stipulated the relationship between pre-litigation procuratorial recommendations and claims as a"consistent"relationship,due to the vague legal provisions and lagging theoretical research,whether the theoretical and practical circles are completely consistent with the purposes of the two,and whether the accuracy of the two is the problems of complete equivalence and how to understand the logical cohesion of the two are not consistent,which seriously affects the standardisation of the judiciary.To this end,the purpose theory,legal supervision theory and the theory of the relationship between pre-litigation procedure and litigation procedure should be used as the basis,and the purpose,the purpose,accuracy and logical relationship between the two should be analysed in an all-round way from the perspective of the purpose of the procedure,the legal function of the procuratorial organ,and the relationship between the pre-litigation procedure and the litigation procedure.

杨雅妮

兰州大学法学院,甘肃兰州 730000

政治法律

行政公益诉讼依法履职诉前检察建议诉讼请求衔接

administrative public interest litigationperforming duty according to lawpre-litigation procuratorial suggestionslitigation claimsconnection

《河北法学》 2024 (007)

32-49 / 18

2021年度国家社科基金西部项目"检察机关办理公益诉讼案件民行刑衔接机制研究"(21XFX015);2023年度甘肃省科技计划资助项目"黄河流域生态保护司法协同机制研究"(23JRZA372).

10.16494/j.cnki.1002-3933.2024.07.003

评论