|国家科技期刊平台

具身何以认知OA北大核心CSSCI

How Does Embodiment Shape Cognition:An Examination of the Historical and Theoretical Aspects Behind"Doing without Learning"

中文摘要英文摘要

"做中学"在实践中往往会变成有"做"而没有"学".在对百年教育改革进程中"做中学"的初衷、异化与乱象进行回顾的基础上,引入认知的具身观点,把"为何有做而没有学"这一现实难题转化为"具身何以认知"这一科学问题,从基于共同编码假说的具身模拟、作为预测器的内部前向模型、扩展想象和行动空间的技术具身之工具合并机制的认知具身三大边界条件出发,对"做中学"为何会变成"有做而没有学"以及如何才能实现"有做亦有学"进行了历史与理论的双重考察.如果说"做中学"以希望开始以失望结束,"发现学习"试图对"做中学"作出超越但最终也归于失败,那么"创中学"基于认知的具身观点则真正实现了对"做中学"和"发现学习"的扬弃与超越,最终实现了"动手"和"动脑"的统一,真正让"做中学"的理想走进教育的现实.可见,"做中学"是正题,"发现学习"是反题,"创中学"则是合题,而这一正反合的三段论隐喻了教育学思想发展与理论建构的辩证统一.

"Learning by doing"often turns into doing without learning in practice.Based on a review of the original intention,alienation and chaos of"learning by doing"in the course of a century of educational reform,this article introduces the embodied per-spective of cognition,thereby transforming the practical problem of"why there is doing without learning"into the scientific question of"how does embodiment shape cognition".Starting from the three major boundaries of embodied cognition(embodied simulation based on the common coding hypothesis,internal forward models as predictors,and the tool incorporation mechanism of technical embodi-ment expanding imagination and action space),the article conducts a dual examination of the historical and theoretical aspects of why"learning by doing"can turn into"doing without learning"and how to achieve"learning by doing".If"learning by doing"begins with hope and ends in disappointment,and"discovery learning"attempts to transcend"learning by doing"but ultimately fails,then"creative learning"based on the embodied cognition viewpoint truly achieves the rejection and transcendence of both"learning by doing"and"discovery learning".It ultimately unifies"doing"and"thinking",allowing the ideal of"learning by doing"to enter the realm of educational reality.It can be seen that"learning by doing"represents the thesis,"discovery learning"is the antithesis,and"creative learning"is the synthesis.This syllogism of thesis,antithesis,and synthesis is a metaphor for the dialectical unity of educa-tional thought development and theoretical construction.

郑旭东;王昕玮

华中师范大学人工智能教育学部(湖北武汉 430079)

教育学

做中学发现学习创中学具身认知

Learning by DoingDiscovery LearningLearning by MakingEmbodied Cognition

《远程教育杂志》 2024 (003)

11-22 / 12

本文系全国教育科学规划2022年度国家一般项目"人工智能促进'三个课堂'应用质量提升的模式与机制研究"(项目编号:SKZ2022-0044)的研究成果.

10.15881/j.cnki.cn33-1304/g4.2024.03.002

评论